100% HCPC-Registered Clinicians · Transparent Fixed Fees · No GP Referral Needed
Eligible Receipts for Simplyhealth, Medicash & Westfield Health · Estimate Cashback →
Physiotherapy · 5 min read · Updated 2026

Sciatica vs Lower Back Pain: How to Tell the Difference & When to See a Physio

Many people with tight glutes or facet joint back pain are told they have 'sciatica' — yet treatment differs meaningfully. Here is how Physiotherapists tell them apart.

Quick Clinical Summary: True sciatica (lumbar radicular pain) usually travels below the knee into the calf or foot with sharp, burning, electric, or pins-and-needles sensations. Mechanical lower back pain stays mainly in the lower back, buttock, or upper thigh and often feels stiff or tight.

Key Differences Between Mechanical Back Pain and Sciatica

Mechanical Lower Back Pain: Driven by sensitive lumbar joints, discs, or protective muscle spasm. Pain is typically felt across the lower back, hips, or upper buttock, worsens with specific bending/lifting or prolonged slouching, and feels dull, tight, or 'locked'.

True Sciatica (Nerve Root Irritation): Caused by inflammation or compression around a nerve root leaving the lower spine (commonly L4, L5, or S1). Leg pain is often WORSE than the back pain itself, shooting down the back/side of the leg below the knee with tingling, numbness, or altered sensation.

Urgent NHS Cauda Equina Red Flags (Never Wait)

Seek immediate emergency medical assessment (A&E or 999) if back or leg pain ever comes with: new loss of control over bladder or bowel, difficulty starting urination or feeling when your bladder is full, numbness/tingling around your groin, genitals or back passage ('saddle anaesthesia'), or sudden severe weakness/foot-drop in one or both legs.

Why Early Physiotherapy Helps Both

Neither condition benefits from prolonged bed rest. An HCPC Physiotherapist runs a careful neurological exam to confirm nerve health, finds pain-relieving positions ('directional preference'), uses gentle manual therapy to calm protective spasm, and guides graded walking and strength so you recover safely without fear.

Editorial & Clinical Standard: Written in line with UK NICE and HCPC professional principles for general patient education. This guide does not replace an individual clinical diagnosis.

Common Questions

Does sciatica usually need surgery?

No — the vast majority of disc-related sciatica episodes settle well over 6–12 weeks with guided Physiotherapy, pacing, and appropriate GP pain management when required.

Ready to sort your pain properly?

HCPC-registered Podiatry & Physiotherapy across Bromley, Beckenham, Ealing & Chiswick. Clear fees, zero GP referral needed.

Symptom Checker Book Appointment →